View RSS Feed

Beam's Blog of Writing and Other Things.

Anime to Manga Comparisons: Sailor Moon S.

Rate this Entry
This is going to be a rather short blog post because I only just recently bought the Sailor Moon manga volume that officially starts the anime's S season arc, but in that small amount of time I've already noticed some pretty interesting differences between the two and wanted to talk about them a bit, largely because my Meioh Shirou continuity deals with the S season of Sailor Moon.

So, shall we dive in?

First off.... whoa is the Haruka/Michiru lesbian antics turned way up to eleven compared to the anime, and that isn't even getting into the mutual 'catch and release' thing Usagi and Haruka have going on for much of this arc. Speaking of Haruka and Michiru, while they're pretty aloof like their anime counterparts, they don't seem as hellbent as trying to be cold-hearted anti-heroes. I kind of like that, even though I know a large part of the difference is because the manga never had the 'find the talismans' arc that the anime does.

As a side note, manga Michiru in civilian dress seems to like wearing a ribbon in her hair. I've already decided to at least touch on friendship!Shirou/Michiru, so that opens up some fun possibilities for me.

Hotaru and her father.... eh. I'm gonna have to wait and see how this develops, but I have to admit so far I'm preferring the anime take on it, where Hotaru is more shy and withdrawn and kind and her father is actually a decent man who got himself into a very bad place trying to save his kid all of those years ago. I'm just a sucker for the whole tragedy of the fact that her father honestly tried to save her and meant no harm, as opposed to the 'evil/uncaring father figure' the manga seems to be building him up towards.

And as a general note: Mamoru. Oh, Mamoru. I have to admit I wasn't too thrilled about him as he was portrayed in the anime, but the manga has really made me warm up to him as a character. I'm still not completely sold on Usagi/Mamoru, mostly because the mangaka seems incapable of writing decent chemistry between characters if they're two mains, but Mamoru himself is a pretty likable guy. He might make a good friend for Shirou.

Setsuna's skin tone seems to vary depending on where you're looking, it seems. In the actual black and white coloring of the manga she appears pretty dark, but on a colored page she's actually even lighter than Archer. Dunno why, I just find that interesting.

.... Also I will admit without shame, the SetsMina shipper in me squealed shamelessly at how bothered Minako seemed by the fact that no one knew about Sailor Pluto's existence and how lonely she was. God, I'm never going to stop shipping these two, am I?

Comments

  1. Aiden's Avatar
    You will never stop shipping those two.

    And it is a good thing.
  2. Alyeris's Avatar
    Correction: The mangaka is incapable of writing decent interaction between characters of different sexes.

    ... and I still stand by my statement that the Moon Kingdom itself is a laughable farce built upon the pillars of mind control and tyranny. Hail the revolution!
  3. Aiden's Avatar
    Eh.

    If mind control is what is needed for a harmonious and orderly society, I'm cool with that!
  4. Laith's Avatar
    Aiden confirmed for agent of the (SMT type of) Law.
  5. RadiantBeam's Avatar
    Quote Originally Posted by Alyeris
    Correction: The mangaka is incapable of writing decent interaction between characters of different sexes.
    Also a very good point! I can accept this correction.
  6. Gabriulio's Avatar
    I agree with you in prefering the anime version of Professor Tomoe, though in my case is because he is an excellent comic relief. Good for you that the manga makes you warm to Mamoru, because for me, in both the anime and the manga he was just... there. I felt as much emotion from him as I felt from Shiki in the Tsukihime VN (which means: nothing, the guy can be a statue all along and I won't be able to tell the difference). Also random SM trivia: Setsuna is half-gypsy.

    Sailor Moon S is, IMO, the best arc of the manga, hope you have fun reading it.
  7. Lycodrake's Avatar
    The manga is probably why I like the series in the first place. Hopefully the new anime will do a whole lot better...
    V-chan is still my favorite.
  8. Aiden's Avatar
    Quote Originally Posted by Laith
    Aiden confirmed for agent of the (SMT type of) Law.
    My favorite Reason in Nocturne is Shijima.